Halifax Police investigate sexual assault at Value Village

 
 

Halifax Regional Police are investigating a sexual assault that occurred in Halifax on Wednesday..

On Wednesday June 28, police received a report of a sexual assault that had occurred at approximately 4:15 p.m. at Value Village located at 165 Chain Lake Drive. While inside the store, a man sexually assaulted a female youth who was not known to him. He then fled the store.

The suspect is described as a white man in his early 30s with dark hair, a skinny build, short facial hair and wearing black skinny jeans and a black and grey plaid long-sleeve shirt. The man was carrying a black duffle bag.

Police are asking anyone with information about the incident or the identity of the suspect, or video from the area to call 902-490-5020.


 

Major Reward Offered in Devon Marsman Case

Devon's story was covered in this Nighttime episode

The missing persons case of Devon Sinclair Marsman has been added to the Nova Scotia Government’s Major Crimes Reward Program.

A reward of up to $150,000 is available for information leading to the arrest and conviction of those responsible for the disappearance of Devon, then 16, who was reported missing by family members on March 4.

Devon was last seen on February 24 in the Halifax area and since that time has not been in contact with anyone. He is described as an African Nova Scotian youth, about five feet tall and 100 pounds, with blue-green eyes and short dark hair. When last seen, he was wearing a hooded sweater and jeans.

Investigators believe people may have information that could result in Devon being located.

Anyone with information should call the Rewards for Major Unsolved Crimes Program at 1-888-710-9090. People who come forward with information must provide their name and contact information and may be called to testify in court. All calls will be recorded.

Anyone with information who prefers to remain anonymous can call Crime Stoppers of Nova Scotia at 1-800-222-TIPS (8477).

Quick Facts:

  • the Rewards for Major Unsolved Crimes Program is an additional tool to help police gather information on unsolved crimes

  • the reward is payable in Canadian funds and will be allocated as deemed just by the Minister of Justice for the Province of Nova Scotia

  • including this case, there are now 111 active cases in the program

  • five cash awards have been paid out since the program started in 2006

  • employees of law enforcement and correctional agencies are not eligible to collect this reward

Cynthia Flemming is Missing in Nova Scotia (Since August 29, 2022)

Colchester County District RCMP is asking for the public's assistance in locating 32-year-old Cynthia Flemming who was last seen on the afternoon of August 29, 2022 on Riverside Ave. in Bible Hill.

Flemming is described as 5-foot- 6, shoulder length blonde hair with dark roots and brown eyes. She has a tattoo on her upper arm of a rose. She was last seen wearing shorts and a tank top, was carrying a large purse and was getting into a maroon SUV.

RCMP investigators have been in contact with Flemming's family and friends, who have not heard from her, and investigators are becoming increasingly concerned for her wellbeing.

When someone goes missing, it has deep and far-reaching impacts for the person and those that know them. We ask that people spread the word through social media respectfully.

Anyone with information on the whereabouts of Cynthia Flemming is asked to contact Colchester County District RCMP at 902-896-5000. Should you wish to remain anonymous, call Nova Scotia Crime Stoppers toll free at 1-800-222-TIPS (8477), submit a secure web tip at www.crimestoppers.ns.ca


Update 1

Statement’s Made by the Man Said to be Cynthia’s Boyfriend

Several hours after the Nova Scotia RCMP issued a press release covering Cynthia’s disappearance Cody Frizzell, who is said to be Cynthia’s long time boyfriend, shared it to his facebook account with the statement “hmmm strange, take notes ladies this why you don’t run off wit randoms”. In follow up comments he further elaborated to allege she made a 911 call in the earlier morning hours of that day.


Update 2 - Sept 9, 2022

Northeast Nova RCMP Major Crime Unit assume lead in investigation into Cynthia Flemming’s disappearance

The Northeast Nova RCMP Major Crime Unit has assumed the lead in the investigation into the disappearance of Cynthia Flemming and released additional photos of her tattoos.


Update 3 - Sept 28, 2022

Cynthia Flemming is Found Deceased

Nova Scotia RCMP have confirmed Cynthia Flemming was located deceased on September 27, in Truro.

RCMP state the investigation into Cynthia's disappearance and death is ongoing, with assistance from the Truro Police Service, and the Nova Scotia Medical Examiner's Office and that at this time it doesn’t appear suspicious. Unofficially, and not unexpectly, rumors of the manner and circumstances of her death are spreading among social media.


Additional photos and links

 


Emily Bailey Update - Jeff Johnson's Home Searched

Hamilton Police Service have spent July 6th and 7th searching the home of Jeff Johnson in relation to the disappearance of 23 year old mother of two Emily Bailey.

Anyone who has listened to the episode series agrees this place should have been searched in January.

My thoughts are with Emily's loved ones during this horrible time.

You can read a Hamilton Spectator article covering the search here:

https://www.thespec.com/news/crime/2022/07/07/hamilton-police-search-east-end-home-in-connection-to-disappearance-of-emily-bailey.html






Nighttime would still like to speak with anyone associated with Jeff Johnson.

Jason Ehler vs Ashley Brown - Another Dark Chapter in the Dylan Ehler case

 
 

Since the May 2020 disappearance of then three year old Dylan Ehler Nighttime has provided frequent updates related to the case. Sadly, the discussion surrounding the case became much less about the search (which has thus far been entirely fruitless) and much more about the dysfunctional relationships that link those associated with the boy.

Up until now the more dramatic moments involved the finger pointing, death threats, and legal motions involving Jason Ehler (Dylan’s father) and Dorothy Parsons (Dylan’s grandmother) which have been well documented on this show (1,2) as well as Jason Ehler’s legal problems which are still before the courts.

Despite the ongoing trials and tribulations the parents of the missing toddler, Jason Ehler and Ashley Brown, have largely maintained a unified front.

As the popular adage goes, it seems this too shall pass.

Something happened on June 18th, 2022 that appears to have driven a spiteful wedge between the pair resulting in Jason publicly expressing suspicions of Ashley Brown in relation to their child’s disappearance, among many other anti social things.

A reader may ask “What caused this drama?”… Here’s an abridged account of what happened told by way of Jason Ehler’s public Facebook posts.

….

The trouble appears to start when Ashley chooses to not participate in a June 18th volunteer search Jason promoted via his Facebook account.

 
 

It gets much more complicated when Jason begins to make public posts which increase in emotion.

 
 

The increase in tone from the prior messages is contextualized when Jason next shares still images from a home security system that appears to show a man leaving Ashley’s place of residence.

 
 
 

The increase of emotion seems to open the door to a frank revelation by Jason Ehler. In the wake of the jealous outburst he, for the first time I’ve seen, publicly expressed suspicion that Ashley Brown could be involved in the disappearance of their son Dylan.

Aside from the casting of suspicion another disturbing layer to this series of events was revealed when Jason Ehler seemed to offer money to whomever could provide him information on the man he suspects to be Ashley Brown’s boyfriend. (i’ve edited the photo to conceal the license plate.)

Based on comments made by Jason it seems Truro Police Services and/or RCMP became involved in the situation however that didn't entirely de-escalate the situation. At the time of writing it seems the situation ended with Jason Ehler publishing personal information for a member of Ashley Brown’s family who appears to be in custody of the reward for Dylan, a commitment to not include Ashley Brown in his search, and statements relating to a new facebook group he plans to create for people who do not support Ashley.

 
 

Sadly, but not surprisingly, this entire mess is the latest in a string of public events and statements that seem to only distract from the missing child at the center of this store. Dylan Ehler.


Update June 20th, 2022

Jason Ehler deletes the majority of his facebook posts related to this series of events and shares an emotional video apology addressing the June 19th statements he made about the unidentified man, Ashley, and Ashley’s possible involvement in Dylan’s disappearance.



View Prior episodes in this series

-

View Prior episodes in this series -

Halifax Police Appeal For Tips Related to Tim Hortons/McDonalds Drive Thru Flasher

Police are continuing to investigate two indecent acts that occurred in Dartmouth last month and are releasing a photo of the suspect.

The case was discussed in a prior episode of Nighttime’s Keep Canada Weird.

On May 27 police responded to a report of an indecent act that had occurred in the drive thru of the McDonald’s restaurant at 144 Main Street. The incident occurred at approximately 4 a.m. that morning where a man exposed himself to staff while waiting for an order.

Later that morning, police received another report of an indecent act that had occurred at approximately 5 a.m. at the Tim Horton’s restaurant located at 365 Pleasant Street. A man, fitting the same description as the suspect in the first incident, exposed himself to staff at the Tim Horton’s drive thru window.

The suspect is described as a white man, between the ages of 25 to 30, short brown or blonde hair with facial hair and blue eyes. The suspect’s vehicle is described as a maroon, 2010-2015 Honda Civic with four doors.

Anyone who may have information in relation to these incidents, or information on the suspect, is asked to call police at 902-490-5020. Anonymous tips can be sent to Crime Stoppers by calling toll-free 1-800-222-TIPS (8477), submitting a secure web tip at www.crimestoppers.ns.ca or by using the P3 Tips app.

Halifax Police Appeal For Tips Related to Two Robberies

Police are investigating two robberies that occurred at the same location in Halifax.

Last year, on November 26, officers responded to a robbery that occurred at Sally Beauty located on Chain Lake Drive.  A woman entered the store, stole merchandise and threatened an employee with a pair of scissors before fleeing on foot.

Yesterday at approximately 2 p.m. officers responded to a robbery that had just occurred at the same Sally Beauty location. Two women came into the store and started stealing merchandise. One of the women had a pair of scissors and used them to threaten a staff member. The two women fled the store on foot with over $1,000 in stolen merchandise.

The suspect with the scissors is believed to be the same person in both incidents. The woman is described as white, in her twenties, approximately 5’2” tall and 120 lbs. with long blonde hair in a ponytail. At the time of the incident, the suspect was wearing a blue jacket.

The second suspect in yesterday’s robbery is described as white, in her twenties, approximately 5'5" tall, 130 lbs. and brown hair. At the time, the suspect was wearing a pink tank top.

Investigators are asking anyone with information about the incidents or video from the area to call 902-490-5020. Anonymous tips can be sent to Crime Stoppers by calling toll-free 1-800-222-TIPS (8477), submitting a secure web tip at www.crimestoppers.ns.ca or using the P3 Tips App.

Dorothy Vs Jason Ehler - the peace bond trial / fraud case updates

In this episode I provide detail and background on the trial related to the peace bond Dylan Ehler's grandmother Dorothy requested against Dylan's father Jason Ehler.

the case, heard via teleconference on April 5, 2022, saw Dorothy present evidence of detailed and explicit death threats made against her and her dog by Jason Ehler. Much like the threats themselves the trial was disorganized, angry, disturbing, and ultimately another dark chapter in the case of missing child Dylan Ehler.


Update - May 16, 2022

It is likely that the peace bond will not provide the intended relief in this battle. Posts made to Facebook by Jason Ehler on May 16th, 2022 seem to show him baiting Dorothy into requesting enforcement of the peace bond (which was previously granted).

 
 

Although this may seem like inconsequential statements on Facebook but breaching conditions of a peace bond is a criminal offence which can lead to a sentence of up to four years imprisonment.

If interested you can read more about peace bonds here.


View Prior episodes in this series

-

View Prior episodes in this series -

Unidentified Child Found Who Resembles Dylan Ehler

I've received many messages/emails about a child found in Ohio on the evening of Feb 17th, 2022 that shows a resemblance to missing Nova Scotian child Dylan Ehler (who was last seen on May 6, 2020)

the unidentified boy, estimated to be 5-7 years old, was found wandering alone by a passerby. The boy is said to be non-verbal and local police are attempting to locate his family.

Although I do see the slight resemblance between this boy and Dylan Ehler I don't feel it's any more than a resemblance. I've posted the photo of the unidentified boy (on the left) and Dylan Ehler (on the right) and would be interested in what YOU think?

unidentified boy

 

Dylan Ehler

 
 

Listen to Nighttime’s Coverage of Dylan Ehler’s disappearance

Jason Ehler Vs. Dorothy - Turmoil in the Dylan Ehler Case

In this episode I provide details of Jason Ehler’s recent court appearance related to an application for a peace bond requested by Dylan’s grandmother Dorothy.

A longer, and much more detailed podcast version which shares Nighttime’s experience with this feud is available on the premium feed


Canada's Worst Mass Murderer's Home and Clinic Demolished (Dartmouth, NS Jan 2022)

𝗖𝗮𝗻𝗮𝗱𝗮'𝘀 𝗪𝗼𝗿𝘀𝘁 𝗠𝗮𝘀𝘀 𝗠𝘂𝗿𝗱𝗲𝗿𝗲𝗿'𝘀 𝗛𝗼𝗺𝗲 𝗮𝗻𝗱 𝗖𝗹𝗶𝗻𝗶𝗰 𝗗𝗲𝘀𝘁𝗿𝗼𝘆𝗲𝗱

Watch this video on Youtube

Gabriel Wortman's denture clinic was demolished.

In this video I provide details of the demolition, video of before during and after, and photos a member of the demolition crew took just prior to the building being leveled.


Jason Ehler Arrested by Truro Police Services

The Truro Police Service have announced they have arrested Jason Ehler (past Nighttime guest and father of missing Dylan Ehler) in a fraud investigation involving three local financial institutions.

In late November, a local bank reported that fraudulent activity had occurred on the account of a deceased customer.

The Truro Police Service Criminal Investigation Division investigated this complaint, gathered evidence, and executed several production orders that revealed that the fraud had occurred at three local banks.

Jason Ehler was arrested Jan 11, 2022 and charged with 11 counts of fraud, 11 counts of forgery, and 11 counts of false pretences with a court date of March 2, 2022.

This investigation remains ongoing and Truro police claim further charges are anticipated.


UPDATE - Statement via Ashley Ehler’s facebook account

 
 

Update 2 - Court Documents Reveal Detail of Allegations

Court information shows Ehler is accused of falsifying cheques written from a Melanie MacCormick to himself for various amounts ranging from $100 to $400 each. He is accused of cashing in and defrauding the TD Bank, Royal Bank of Canada and Bank of Montreal in Truro, on occasions from Nov. 15 to 23, 2021.


Update 3 - Jason Ehler (or affiliate) issues takedown request

In a not completely surprising update someone writing from a Jason Ehler named Facebook account requested this post be removed. After the release of a prior Nighttime episode, which included an interview with Dorothy Parsons, a similar message was sent that also ended with “you’ll hear from my lawyer”.

 

Update 4 - March 2nd Court Appearance

Jason’s lawyer made a court appearance on his behalf requesting a postponement of his hearing until a later date. The request was approved and the case will now be heard on April 6th at 930am.

Additional information related to the charges against Mr. Ehler will shared during this hearing.


the Riverview Hospital (Coquitlam, BC)

We all have the choice to learn what are often difficult truths behind how our society functions. We can also choose to stay willfully ignorant to the dark shadows that look over our everyday existence. This existential concept is the main premise behind the Matrix film series. The newest installment of the Matrix uses the Riverview Hospital, in Coquitlam B.C as a filming location. The Matrix franchise is not the first to use Riverview Hospital. The hospital has become a staple in horror and suspense films and series productions in Canada. You can see it featured in X-Files, Smallville, Riverdale series and horror films: Halloween Resurrection, Butterfly Effect, Final Destination 2, Shutter Island along with many others. This location is quietly nestled in the small suburban city of Coquitlam less than 15km outside Vancouver, British Columbia. Some might recognize Coquitlam as the home of Robert Pickton, one of Canada’s most horrific serial killers.

The Riverview Hospital was a mental health institution built over a century ago with a long and dark history. The walls have borne witness to many tragic events. It is thought to house many more ghosts than patients these days. With only a few patients still occupying one of the older buildings, mostly in high-security units for those deemed criminally insane.

Riverview mental health asylum opened in 1904. The institution was built on 405 hectares of land. During its inception, the intention was to have the facilities located in a beautiful natural setting, which even included its farm, Colony Farm, which would help the therapeutic treatment of patients. By 1913, the first permanent ward opened, and quickly it was filled to double its capacity with over 900 patients. It is thought that the institution had good intentions and was considered extremely progressive for its time and even recognized as a model of psychiatric care. Perhaps this was true, but upon opening its doors the sheer over-capacity from the beginning created an environment where the conditions were extremely poor. Over the next few years, more wards opened up: The Boys Industrial School for Juvenile Delinquents, an Acute Psychopathic Unit, a Female Chronic Building, and a Veterans' Block opened for shell shock patients from the First World War to name a few. By 1956 the asylum housed upward of 5,000 patients.

Definitions of insanity in the 21st century are quite different from today. Patients ranged from those who had run-ins with the law to women who were committed by their relatives for not performing their gender roles accordingly. During this period, men were often committed to afflictions that were hereditary such as mania and depression. While also being locked up for

intemperance, syphilis, and masturbation.

Many experiments and treatments were used at this institution that is now seen as barbaric, and lawsuits were filed against the hospital in later years. Between 1940 and 1968 the B.C. government had embraced eugenics, and sterilization was common at the Riverview Hospital. It was believed that the sterilization of people with mental health issues, criminals, and even the poor would improve society. Most of the sterilizations occurred with women patients. In 2005, 9 women who experienced this traumatic procedure were awarded $450,000. There were close to 200 women sterilized during 1940-1968. By the 1960s, patient numbers were declining in part because of the introduction of psychiatric medications and hospitals opening up psychiatric wards on site.

By the 1980s, society's views of mental health issues and treatment had shifted. Over 30 years many patients were released and the institutions began to crumble. There are different sentiments on the shutting down of mental illness asylums. While the Riverview Hospital had poor conditions, controversial treatments and, like other institutions at the time, patients that did not warrant being there at all. There were facets of their institution that can be viewed favourably.

Closing its doors may seem like a victory but releasing patients after enduring traumatic experiences and many still suffering mental health issues without any help was disastrous. This happened all over Canada and many people with mental health issues who were living in these institutions became unhoused. Many Riverview Hospital patients ended up on the streets of the downtown eastside in Vancouver, a location known today for desperate people living in the direst and impoverished situations. Others ended up in the prison system.

In the 2000s, Riverview and the BC government were heavily criticized for the use of practices such as electroshock therapy, hydrotherapy and induced insulin comas. Electroshock therapy is a controversial psychiatric treatment in which a generalized seizure is imposed on the brain through electronic “shocks”. This treatment has been heavily criticized and has become less common today, though still used in some circumstances. An inquiry was done at Riverview Hospital into the elevated use of the treatment when it coincided with the doctors being paid extra when giving the procedure. In December 2000, staff at the hospital contacted the provincial health minister of British Columbia with concern over the alarming rate Shock Therapy was being administered. The use of the treatment had doubled since the extra compensation to doctors had begun. Hydrotherapy was another controversial treatment given to patients who suffered insomnia, restlessness and acute psychosis. This treatment involved patients being put in hot baths for up to 9 hours at a time. Insulin Coma Therapy was another disputed treatment in which patients were repeatedly injected with large doses of insulin to induce daily comas for several weeks. This was often given to patients suffering from Schizophrenia.

It would be dishonest to paint a picture of the institution as just an abusive, decrepit asylum for the duration of its history. Looking at the larger picture, the Riverview Hospital was also a highly functioning and interesting case study for self-sufficiency. Riverview Hospital at its peak had 80 buildings on site and had created a self-sufficient mini-society. Colony Farm and its patient workers were producing large amounts of crops and milk. This is considered a form of Occupational Therapy, where work is given as a positive alternative to confinement and punishment. Within this mini-society was a post office, bakery, chapel, cinema, bowling alley, Firehall, bus station and more. The institution hosted parades, picnics and sports on the ground. Many patients lived at the hospital for 20 or 30 years until they were released upon it shutting down. While the institution itself must be held accountable for its actions in harming people, especially within the context of grandiose misuse of medical treatments for financial gain. This place could also be seen as an example of an institution mirroring negative ways in which the larger society views certain people and how they are to be dealt with during a specific time. The Riverview hospital was using practices that were heavily supported by the government and were not uncommon during that period across North America.

Today, the grounds of Riverview hold many decrepit abandoned buildings which are often visited by urban explorers and ghost hunters. The grounds are home to an arboretum of over 1,900 trees and much wildlife. Outside of being a popular spooky filming location, this year, a new mental health and addictions rehab facility was built on the ground. Despite a land claim by the Kwkikwetlem First Nation that has been in the works for 20 years, requesting the land to be returned to its original indigenous custodians, rather than for continued development of new institutions and housing projects. The new facility that has just been built is once again seen as a modern advanced space for mental health support, much like its predecessor. We can only hope that in our modern days of more understanding of mental health it can be of support rather than cause harm.

Researched and Written by Monica Victoria

Related Links:

https://vancouver.citynews.ca/2020/11/30/riverview-hospital-coquitlam-psychiatric/

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/bc-probes-big-increase-in-shock-

treatments/article18428557/

https://vancouversun.com/news/closure-of-riverview-hospital-marks-end-of-era-in-mental-health-

treatment

REFERENCES:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_pill_and_blue_pill

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/british-columbia/dark-history-may-temper-public-input-

on-former-hospital-at-riverview/article17131074/

https://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/robert-pickton-case

Erin Brooks is Missing in New Brunswick (Since Dec 27, 2021)

Fredericton Police is investigating the disappearance of 38-year-old Erin Brooks, who was last seen on Fredericton’s Northside on December 27, 2021.

Erin Brooks was last seen wearing blue jeans, a black jacket and black boots. She is 5’6” , approximately 115lbs, has brown eyes and brown hair with bangs. She was seen at the St. Mary’s Smoke Shop in the evening of December 27.

Anyone with information about Erin Brooks is asked to contact the Fredericton Police Force, at 506-460-2300 or Crime Stoppers at 1-800-222-8477.

the Murder of Joe Rose (1989 Montreal, Qc)

a video version is available on Youtube

On the night of March 19, 1989, Joe Rose and his friend Sylvain Dutil were returning home to their Montréal east-end AIDS Hospice after a night out at a gay bar. Joe Rose had been experiencing disabling AIDS symptoms but had decided it would be nice to go out and enjoy the evening. Tragically, that evening would end horrifically for Rose and become one of the most shocking hate crimes in Canadian history.

Joe Rose Jr. was born in North Sydney, Cape Breton, Nova Scotia. As a young child Rose moved with his family to Montréal, Quebec. At the age of 16 years old, he had come out openly as gay.  In 1985, Rose founded Etcetera a queer association and club at Dawson College, a large anglophone CEGEP right in the heart downtown of Montréal. Rose was studying Nursing at the college. 

Rose also had hopes of forming a Montréal chapter of ACT UP (AIDS Coalition to Unleash Power),  an international grassroots activist group fighting to improve conditions of people living with AIDS. The group organized  through direct actions and demonstrations to help improve medical treatment and research and government policies and legislations.  Rose was dedicated to Queer activism and later studied Journalism at Concordia University, writing for the University newspaper The Link.  Friends described Rose as brave and brazen, with flamboyant pink hair he was out and proud of being gay. He was also open about his HIV positive status, fighting for the de-stigmatization of people living with HIV/AIDS.  Friends claimed that Rose believed that people needed to be open about who they were, as he hoped that it would help change things in the world. Rose’s brother Geoffrey, whom he was close to, being only a few years in age apart; spoke of him as a loving person and proud of who he was stating “he didn’t have a hateful bone in his body”. 

The night of March 19, Rose and Sylvain Dutil embarked on the No. 358 eastbound night bus from Atwater metro after their night out.  Rose had invited Geoffrey to come out with them that night, but his brother was playing a show at another venue that evening.  While riding the bus home, a group of teenagers began taunting the two young men calling them homophobic slurs. Three minors ages 14 and 15, and 19-year-old Patrick Moise began attacking the two. Dutil escaped with minor injuries but Joe was kicked, struck in the head and stabbed. Dutil attempted to resuscitate Rose until the police arrived a few minutes later but Rose had succumbed to his injuries. He was only 23 years old.  The public transportation system was later criticized because the bus driver did not hit the emergency button when the attack began, a measure that buses had for emergency situations like this. 

It was especially dangerous for people from the queer community during this time period including in Montreal.  The HIV/AIDS crisis had created a dangerous environment for queer people. Not just because of the risks of the virus itself, but because of the scape-goating used towards the community, unjustly blaming them for its existence. Homophobia and violence had become more common, and government neglect of the tragic situation allowed thousands of vulnerable people to get sick and die. There were many 2SLGBTQIA+ (two spirit lesbian gay bisexual trans queer intersex asexual etc ) hate crimes and unsolved murders at the time. Murders of queer people were often taken less seriously because of societal homophobia, which also unfortunately happens to other marginalized groups as well. 

A year after the brutal crime the murderers were finally sentenced. The three minors were sentenced to a few months each in youth custody.  Moise who was legally an adult at the time of the murder was sentenced to 7 years in prison.  Rose’s parents sued the transportation company, the STCUM (Société de transport de la Communauté urbaine de Montréal) at the time, for failing to alert authorities during the event and were awarded 25,000$.  This murder was one of several murders that took place on and around the cities public transportation system, which forced the STCUM  to review their safety protocols.  

With much pressure from Rose’s  father, Maurice Rose, there was also  a review of the Young Offenders Act, which was the standard at the time for minors on trial; which often led to light sentences, such as the ones given in this case. Maurice Rose believed that this act allowed young offenders too much opportunity to get away with violent crimes. The Young Offenders Act replaced the Juvenile Delinquents Act in 1984. The act intended to promote the ideas of rehabilitation rather than punishment. Instead of being incarcerated in prisons, youth are sent to treatment centres or therapeutic homes. For Rose Jr’ s father the punishment was not severe enough for the crime that ended his son’s life. 

This merciless crime fueled an uproar of queer activism charged by anger surrounding  the danger people of this orientation faced in their daily lives. The years of 1989- 1994  are considered crucial in the history of queer activism in Montréal.  Three months later after the murder, the 2SLGBTQIA+ of Montréal stormed the stage of the AIDS conference, demanding space to speak of their concerns. ACTUP opened an office in Montréal and organized a “die-in” protest at the Complex Desjardins in Montréal  on the year anniversary of Rose’s death.  

Today 33 years later,  Montréal is a city like others in Canada with many large active queer communities  both within a cultural sense and that of social  activism and organizing.  While things have changed since the late eighties/ early nineties in some respects,  history does not always progressively move forward. History seems to exist more like a pendulum alongside societal events and political changes. People from the 2SLGBTQIA+communities  today still have to deal with the fear of violence. While being openly queer is much more common when you walk down the street in Montréal today.  Queer people deal with many challenges in our society simply to exist.

Many queer people still deal with being disowned by their families, difficulty securing safe housing, not being given appropriate medical care, not getting the same work opportunities  and the threat of violence. These days that is especially in  the case with Transgender and gender non-conforming  people, that violence is especially prevalent. Specifically,  groups such as trans women of colour are disproportionality murdered at an alarming rate. With the rise of  alt-right ideologies and neo-conservative movements, being able to exist safely as part of a marginalized group has become more difficult and scary.  Perhaps we have a responsibility as a community to educate ourselves and others about acceptance and co-existence with others who may be different from us. It is important to share these stories so that we can learn and not continue the cycle of bigotry, indifference and violence towards others.

-Researched and written by Monica Victoria

Links:

Video Version

https://www.saltwire.com/atlantic-canada/news/cape-breton-born-mans-1989-murder-fuelled-intensified-lgbt-activistism-in-quebec-100621579/

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/joe-rose-murder-30-years-1.5062744

https://montrealgazette.com/news/montreal/prejudice-to-pride-the-forgotten-murder-of-joe-rose

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joe_Rose_(activist)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ACT_UP

https://montrealgazette.com/news/montreal/prejudice-to-pride-the-forgotten-murder-of-joe-rose

https://elkascott.wordpress.com/2019/06/23/canadian-crime-stories-episode-one-the-murder-of-joe-rose-and-the-cost-of-nice-things/

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/joe-rose-frontenac-metro-1.5340281